"A Big fat hit!" - New York Post
"Something Rotten! is The Producers + Spamalot + The Book of Mormon. Squared!" –New York Magazine
"5 stars! Broadway's funniest musical comedy in at least 400 years!" - Time Out New York
"The funniest thing since The Book of Mormon!" - AP
"Yep, this is a Blockbuster! Broadway hits have a white-hot energy: everything clicks into place, the actors are firing on all cylinders — and the audience knows it's watching something special. Now, that something special is Something Rotten!: a deliriously entertaining new musical comedy that brings down the house!" – New York Post
"I have never had a better time on Broadway!" - New York Observer
"Fresh, irreverent and hysterical!" - AP
"Musical nirvana!" - The Wrap
"Ingenious! Outrageous! Irresistible!" Variety
"Far from rotten, it's awesome!" - AP
"Something Rotten! is the complete oposite of its title!" - Entertainment Weekly
"Something Rotten! reeks with originality!" - Entertainment Weekly
"The most original, funniest show of the season!" ABC Radio
"A howling Broadway smash!" - New Jersey Newsroom
"Something Rotten! has just about the all-time greatest staged number in the history of musical comedy!" - NPR
"Something Rotten! is an explosion of musical joy!" - NPR
"Fun! Fun! Fun! When was the last time you got your money's worth of that at a Broadway show?" - Deadline